BlogCarnivore RecipesHealthy High-Protein Brownies (Fudgy, Gooey, 205 Calories Each)High Protein RecipeKeto RecipesLow-CarbRecipeSuccess StoriesWW Recipes

Ninja Creami Vanilla Protein Ice Cream (Ultra Creamy, High-Protein)

Updated on 3 min read

Quick Description

This Ninja Creami Vanilla Protein Ice Cream is thick, creamy, and tastes like classic vanilla soft serve — but made with just a few simple, high-protein ingredients. Using a Fairlife Core Power shake and sugar-free pudding mix, it delivers a smooth, scoopable texture with minimal effort. Perfect for a high-protein dessert, late-night sweet craving, or post-workout treat.

Servings & Timing

Serves: 1 pint
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Freeze Time: Minimum 12 hours
Spin Time: 2–3 minutes
Total Time: ~12 hours

Equipment

  • Ninja Creami
  • Large mixing bowl
  • Whisk

Ingredients List

Standard Pint

  • 14 oz Fairlife Core Power Vanilla Protein Shake
  • 1 tbsp stevia
  • 1 tbsp sugar-free instant vanilla pudding mix

Deluxe Pint

  • 21 oz Fairlife Core Power Vanilla Protein Shake
  • 2 tbsp stevia
  • 2 tbsp sugar-free instant vanilla pudding mix

Instructions

Part One: Mix & Freeze

  1. In a large mixing bowl, add:
    • Protein shake
    • Stevia
    • Sugar-free pudding mix
  2. Whisk well until the stevia is fully dissolved and no dry lumps remain.
    (The pudding mix will not fully dissolve — this is normal.)
  3. Let the mixture sit for 30–60 seconds so bubbles settle.
  4. Pour the mixture into a clean Ninja Creami pint.
  5. Cover with the lid and freeze on a level surface for at least 12 hours.

Part Two: Spin & Serve

  1. Remove pint from freezer and place into Ninja Creami machine.
  2. Select Lite Ice Cream (or Ice Cream, depending on preference).
  3. If crumbly after first spin, add 1–2 tbsp milk and re-spin using Re-Spin.
  4. Scoop and enjoy immediately.

Nutrition (Standard Pint – Approximate)

  • Calories: ~170–190
  • Protein: 26–30g
  • Carbs: 5–7g
  • Fat: 2–3g
  • Sugar: 2g

(Nutrition varies slightly by Core Power version.)

Benefits

  • High-Protein: Keeps you full and satisfied
  • Low Sugar: Sweet without spikes
  • Creamy Texture: Pudding mix creates perfect consistency
  • Minimal Ingredients: Simple and reliable every time

Additional Notes

  • Do not overfill pint past the max line
  • Always freeze completely solid for best results
  • Let pint sit on counter 2–3 minutes if extremely hard

Dietary Info

  • High-Protein: Yes
  • Low Sugar: Yes
  • Gluten-Free: Yes
  • Keto-Friendly: Mostly (depends on protein shake)

Brief Introduction

This Creami recipe is one of the easiest ways to turn a protein shake into a real dessert. It’s smooth, creamy, and endlessly customizable — a staple for anyone using the Ninja Creami regularly.

Step-by-Step Cooking Guide

  1. Whisk ingredients
  2. Let bubbles settle
  3. Freeze 12 hours
  4. Spin in Creami
  5. Re-spin if needed
  6. Enjoy

Ingredient Details & Substitutions

  • Protein Shake: Any Fairlife or similar shake works
  • Stevia: Can replace with monk fruit or erythritol
  • Pudding Mix: Essential for creaminess (use sugar-free)

Recipe Variations & Serving Suggestions

Chocolate Version

Use chocolate protein shake + chocolate pudding mix.

Birthday Cake

Add sugar-free sprinkles after spinning.

Cookies & Cream

Fold in crushed high-protein cookies after first spin.

Storage & Make-Ahead

  • Best eaten immediately after spinning
  • Can be re-frozen and re-spun later if needed

You may also like...